← All episodes

Guide

What Do You Say the Night Before a College Decision? One Letter, 8 Lines

The 8-line letter two parents wrote their daughter the night before her first college decision, plus how to write your own. By The Nick Standlea Show.

Video published 2023-09-13 · 0:59 · watch on YouTube

The short answer

Two parents wrote their daughter an 8-line letter the night before her first college response, and they told her their pride would not change based on what admissions officers decide. The most difficult part of the admissions process is getting rejected, because it feels personal, and a letter written before the news lands takes that sting away.

Step by step

  1. Why write the letter before the decision and not after?

    Because the letter is dated the night before the first college response, and that timing is the whole point. The parents said their piece while the answer was still unknown.

  2. What does each line of the letter do?

    Line 1 opens with pride that is already settled, before any college has said anything. The letter builds from there in a simple order.

  3. How do I write my own version of this letter?

    Make the three moves this letter makes, in this order, and stop. The letter does them in 8 lines, so you can too.

  4. What should I do the morning the decision arrives?

    Say nothing new, and let the letter stand. You already said the important part the night before.

  5. Does a letter like this really change anything?

    It changes what the kid thinks the decision means, which is the part that hurts. The most difficult part of the admissions process is getting rejected, because it feels personal.

The letter is 8 lines long, and that is enough The whole letter runs 8 lines. It is short on purpose. A kid who is nervous will not read a page. They will read eight sentences, and they will read them more than once.

Line 3 does the heaviest lifting Line 3 says the pride will not change based on what admissions officers decide. That is the one idea a kid needs the night before. It sets the result and the love apart before the result exists.

Written before the news, not after The parents dated it the night before the first college response. Written after a rejection, the same 8 lines read like a bandage. Written before, they read like the truth.

What did the letter actually say?

Here is the letter in full, in order, as the parents wrote it and as I read it in the short. The word in line 5 is their word, and I left it alone.

LineText
1Dear Sarah, on the night before you receive your first college response we wanted to let you know that we could not be any prouder of you than we are today.
2Whether or not you get accepted does not determine how proud we are of everything you have accomplished and the wonderful person you have become.
3That will not change based on what admissions officers decide about your future.
4We will celebrate with joy wherever you get accepted, and the happier you are with those responses the happier we will be.
5But your worth as a person, a student and our daughter is not diminished or influenced in the least by what these colleges have decided.
6If it does not go your way, you will take a different route to get where you want.
7There is not a single college in this country that would not be lucky to have you, and you are capable of succeeding at any of them.
8We love you as deep as the ocean, as high as the sky, all the way around the world and back again, and to wherever you are headed. Love, Mom and Dad.

Source: transcript of the video, punctuated; the parents' own words. 8 lines in all.

Why write the letter before the decision and not after?

Because the letter is dated the night before the first college response, and that timing is the whole point. The parents said their piece while the answer was still unknown.

A letter after a rejection sounds like comfort. A kid hears it as a response to bad news, and bad news is what they are already feeling. The same words sent the night before sound like a fact about the family.

I have coached families through college decisions since 2009. The night before is the hardest night. Kids refresh a portal, read old essays, and run every outcome in their head.

Handing them something to read that night gives them one quiet minute that is not about colleges. That is all a parent can control on that day.

What does each line of the letter do?

Line 1 opens with pride that is already settled, before any college has said anything. The letter builds from there in a simple order.

Lines 2 and 3 split the result from the pride. Line 3 is the hinge: pride will not change based on what admissions officers decide. Line 4 gives the good news room. The parents say they will celebrate with joy wherever she gets accepted, so the letter is not bracing only for a no.

Line 5 is the parents' own sentence about her as a person, a student and a daughter. Line 6 names the other path plainly: she will take a different route to get where she wants.

Lines 7 and 8 end wide open. No college in this country would be anything but lucky to have her, and the love runs to wherever she is headed.

How do I write my own version of this letter?

Make the three moves this letter makes, in this order, and stop. The letter does them in 8 lines, so you can too.

First, say the pride is already true today. Do not tie it to a school name or a result. Second, name the two outcomes out loud. Say you will celebrate a yes, and say a no sends them on a different route. Kids trust a parent who says the hard half.

Third, end on something personal that has nothing to do with school. These parents used the ocean and the sky. Use whatever your family already says at bedtime or on the phone.

Write it by hand if you can. Keep it to one page. Leave it on a pillow or a desk the night before, and do not stand there while they read it.

What should I do the morning the decision arrives?

Say nothing new, and let the letter stand. You already said the important part the night before.

Decisions for fall 2027 applicants arrive from mid-December 2026 through early April 2027. That is a long stretch, so plan for a normal day around each one. Keep dinner, keep practice, keep the drive to school.

If the answer is yes, celebrate it the way they want to celebrate, not the way you want to post it. If the answer is no, do not rush to fix it. A kid who just got turned down does not want a plan in the first hour.

Later that week, go back to line 6. There is a different route, and naming it calmly is more useful than naming it fast.

Does a letter like this really change anything?

It changes what the kid thinks the decision means, which is the part that hurts. The most difficult part of the admissions process is getting rejected, because it feels personal.

A college read an application. It did not read your child. When a kid has a letter from a parent that says that in plain words, a thin envelope stays a college result instead of a verdict on a person.

I have coached families through these nights since 2009, and the letter gives a family a clear thing to say first. Line 3 and line 6 are the two lines a kid can hold onto when the screen loads.

You do not need the right words. You need your words, written down, before the news.

Method and sources: The source is a single short video from The Nick Standlea Show, in which Nick reads a letter two parents wrote their daughter the night before her first college decision. The table is the letter itself, punctuated from the transcript, kept in the parents' own words and in their original order across all 8 lines. This page holds no study data, no admission rates and no survey results, and none should be read into it. The family is one family, and the letter is one example rather than a tested method. Decision dates named here apply to the fall 2027 application cycle.

Questions people ask

When should I give my kid the letter?

Leave it on a pillow or a desk the night before, and do not stand there while they read it.

How long should the letter be?

The whole letter runs 8 lines.

Why not wait and write it only if my kid gets rejected?

A letter after a rejection sounds like comfort.

What is the one idea the letter has to include?

Line 3 says the pride will not change based on what admissions officers decide.

Should I mention the chance of a rejection at all?

Kids trust a parent who says the hard half.

What do I say the morning the news arrives?

Say nothing new, and let the letter stand.

When do decisions come out this cycle?

Decisions for fall 2027 applicants arrive from mid-December 2026 through early April 2027.

What if I am not a good writer?

You do not need the right words.

This guide is drawn from a full conversation on the show.

All guides · Sponsor the show

Field Notes

The sharpest idea from every conversation.

A short dispatch for people who'd rather understand than scroll — one big idea from each guest, distilled. Free, most weeks. Unsubscribe anytime.